LUCA SIGNORELLI AND STUDIO | THE MADONNA AND CHILD WITH SAINTS BERNARD(?), ANTHONY OF PADUA AND JOHN THE EVANGELIST(?)

Possibly in a private collection, Florence, 1955 (according to a note on a photograph in the Berenson collection at Villa I Tatti, Florence);

With Central Picture Galleries, New York (as Luca Signorelli), by whom sold to

Marc and Lillian Rojtman on November 22, 1959;

By whose estate sold, New York, Sotheby's, January 28, 2005, lot 523;

Anonymous sale ("Property from a Private California Collection"), New York, Sotheby's, 3 June 2010, lot 7;

Where acquired by the present collector. 

Pharos, Museum of Fine Arts, St. Petersburg, Florida, Winter 1968, vol. VI, no. 4, reproduced in color on the cover;

T. Henry, The Complete Paintings of Luca Signorelli, London 2001, p. 211, under cat. no. 70.

The painting relates directly to an autograph work by Signorelli today in a private collection in Italy (reproduced in T. Henry, see Literature, p. 211, cat. no. 70). In Henry's opinion this version, which is faithful to the original in every detail, was painted under Signorelli's supervision in his workshop and he believes that he may have been involved in parts of the picture's execution. He dates the present variant to circa 1510, slightly after the other tondo which is generally believed to have been painted and paid for in 1505. When last sold (see Provenance) Laurence Kanter endorsed the attribution to Luca Signorelli with workshop assistance.